Sapphistries rupp leila j. Sapphistries : a global history of love between women : Rupp, Leila J., 1950 2019-03-24

Sapphistries rupp leila j Rating: 5,5/10 815 reviews

Book Review: Sapphistries by Leila J. Rupp

sapphistries rupp leila j

I helped to build a curriculum, hire other faculty, develop a minor and major, and do all the things that make a place for a new discipline within the university. From the ancient poet Sappho to tombois in contemporary Indonesia, women throughout history and around the globe have desired, loved, and had sex with other women. The great world religions had something to say about female same-sex sexuality. Giving voice to words from the mouths and pens of women, and from men's prohibitions, reports, literature, art, imaginings, pornography, and court cases, Rupp also creatively employs fiction to imagine possibilities when there is no historical evidence. Love between women was not unknown in other woman-only places, and in some societies it was deemed harmless or even desirable for women who lived in polygynous households, as it made for more harmonious relations between co-wives.

Next

Sapphistries: A Global History of Love between Women

sapphistries rupp leila j

Giving voice to words from the mouths and pens of women, and from men's prohibitions, reports, literature, art, imaginings, pornography, and court cases, Rupp also creatively employs fiction to imagine possibilities when there is no historical evidence. Feminist studies combines basic skills with specific knowledge in a way that opens up many possibilities. Turning to societies that have left us historical evidence, including Egyptian, Chinese, Indian, Inca, Aztec and Greek and Roman civilizations, we first encounter Sappho of Lesbos, who bequeathed her name and country of origin to so many of the terms for woman-loving women. And we encounter a world of difference in the twenty-first century, as transnational concepts and lesbian identities meet local understandings of how two women might love each other. The author attempts to answer these questions in the beginning, stating that for the purpose of the text she will only be examining those who have acted upon their sexual desires for women. Rupp states in the introduction of her book that she intends to read into history with the intention of drawing out lesbian representation, but I can't respect her for doing this at the expense of representation of the trans community. While this is fine for what is basically a regurgitation of female same-sex evidence throughout history, I would have liked to have gained some insight on the complexities of human sexuality on an instinctual level.

Next

Sapphistries : a global history of love between women : Rupp, Leila J., 1950

sapphistries rupp leila j

Sometimes it seems to have been titillating. An entire book on the semi-mythical Amazons of ancient Anatolia would be particularly welcome, if anyone could recommend such a work. Sapphistries combines lyrical narrative with meticulous historical research, providing an eminently readable and uniquely sweeping story of desire, love, and sex between women around the globe from the beginning of time to the present. He tells it like it is—a dose of raw, refreshing, honest truth that is sorely lacking today. In beautiful prose, Sapphistries tells their stories, capturing the multitude of ways that diverse societies have shaped female same-sex sexuality across time and place.

Next

Sapphistries : a global history of love between women : Rupp, Leila J., 1950

sapphistries rupp leila j

It isn't a global history at all, just another one that focuses on the west with a couple of random and incorrect examples from different cultures thrown in without any thought to culture, or time period. In beautiful prose, Sapphistriestells their stories, capturing the multitude of ways that diverse societies have shaped female same-sex sexuality across time and place. Yet all the ancient societies valued men over women. But of course general introductions are in need, so this serves well enough as that. One may say that it is as ambitious as love between women has proven to be audacious. She wanted to write a traditional book on 'homosexuality', and I take it as such.

Next

Sapphistries by Leila J. Rupp · OverDrive (Rakuten OverDrive): eBooks, audiobooks and videos for libraries

sapphistries rupp leila j

. Rupp, however, makes no attempt to include people assigned male at birth who may well have identified as women and loved women themselves. The author comes close to discussing this when revealing the study of hermaphrodites as it related to women loving women, but anything beyond that is ignored. In beautiful prose, Sapphistries tells their stories, capturing the multitude of ways that diverse societies have shaped female same-sex sexuality across time and place. Her only discerning point seems to be the genitals of the people in love, as a vagina is really the only thing all her subjects have in common. Synopsis What does it mean to be black in a nation increasingly infatuated with colorblindness? We find women's desire and love for women meeting the light of day as Japanese schoolgirls fall in love, and lesbian bars and clubs spread from 1920s Berlin to 1950s Buffalo.

Next

Book Review: Sapphistries by Leila J. Rupp

sapphistries rupp leila j

Whether your relationship is flourishing or failing, Dr. Although the book would have been stronger had the author been able to integrate the impact of racism and colonialism into her analysis, her claims are made with great care, and with sensitivity to cultural nuance. Weighting themselves with stones, they threw themselves into the Sea of Japan. There was no such thing as women's studies, but my professors were very supportive of my passion for studying women in all of my classes. Sixty six pages of endnotes attest to the seriousness of the work; over two hundred pages of lucid and accessible prose make history fun again. I would still recommend this book for any lesbian looking to learn about Sapphic history, but I would also warn them not to expect much in terms of knowing what makes us tick on the inside.

Next

Sapphistries by Leila J. Rupp by Leila J. Rupp

sapphistries rupp leila j

Sapphistries combines lyrical narrative with meticulous historical research, providing an eminently readable and uniquely sweeping story of desire, love, and sex between women around the globe from the beginning of time to the present. Rupp reveals how, from the time of the very earliest societies, the possibility of love between women has been known, even when it is feared, ignored, or denied. Rupp, Sapphistries: A Global History of Love between Women New York: New York University Press, 2009. Joan Nestle, co-editor of GenderQueer Sapphistries is amazing. New York: New York University Press, 2009.

Next

Sapphistries: A Global History of Love between Women · cbetskc.com

sapphistries rupp leila j

We hear women in the sex-segregated spaces of convents and harems whispering words of love. Still, it seemed the author is seduced by labels created by the very society that repressed and still continues to repress homosexuals. What was new was the beginning of a sense of a community of women with common interests, as well as public awareness of more than a single couple engaging in sexual activity. Overall, however, I did find the book full of sources I was interested to know more about, even if I wished they had been put to better use by the author. These included urban groups of women, women in brothels and prisons, aristocratic European women, marriage resisters in China, and romantic friends in Europe and the United States.

Next

Sapphistries by Leila J. Rupp by Leila J. Rupp

sapphistries rupp leila j

In part this is a result of widespread female illiteracy, especially among the lower classes, and in part it is the result of the deliberate destruction of women's writings. But to include trans men in a study of women's love throughout global history, while neglecting to mention even a single trans woman who loved women Lili Elbe springs to mind as important to a historical study such as this is extremely difficult for me to understand - unless the author believes firmly that biology trumps presentation and personal identification, which I hope is not the case. We see women beginning to find each other on the streets of London and Amsterdam, in the aristocratic circles of Paris, in the factories of Shanghai. Rupp's contribution is perhaps one of the most elegant and interesting-making up for the lapses of the past, Sapphistries sails an international course, giving us a rich mix of historical sources and an even richer gift of asking questions at just the right places. We see women beginning to find each other on the streets of London and Amsterdam, in the aristocratic circles of Paris, in the factories of Shanghai. The sources amassed were wide-ranging, though mostly from a Western perspective, and many were new to me, including 'the Arab Sappho', a love spell addressed from one woman to another in Roman-era Egypt, and many Chinese 'May Fourth' writers and thinkers. These included schoolgirls, feminists, attendees at the influential Paris salon of Natalie Barney, women in the lesbian commercial establishments that emerged in New York, Paris, and Berlin in the 1920s and in other less urban places in the 1950s, and readers of lesbian publications and members of lesbian organizations from the 1920s on.

Next

Book Review: Sapphistries by Leila J. Rupp

sapphistries rupp leila j

Giving voice to words from the mouths and pens of women, and from men's prohibitions, reports, literature, art, imaginings, pornography, and court cases, Rupp also creatively employs fiction to imagine possibilities when there is no historical evidence. We find women's desire and love for women meeting the light of day as Japanese schoolgirls fall in love, and lesbian bars and clubs spread from 1920s Berlin to 1950s Buffalo. The greater the presumed masculinity of lesbian women, the greater the economic, political, social and sexual independence of lesbian women, the more fierce the repression. Estelle Freedman, author of No Turning Back Every decade or so, a brave thinker makes an attempt to chart the historical maps of women loving women. That could be misconstrued very badly in a book on 'love between women', but I think I know where Rupp is coming from.

Next